Electric Heater Concept

Prior to development, several existing and potential technologies (e.g. wire-wound resistance or positive temperature coefficient (PTC) heating) were analysed. Four main development objectives were evaluated and several potential technologies were compared with respect to these objectives:

(1) In terms of efficiency, the new heater must be highly efficient in that it should be able to provide the required heat output over a wide range of coolant temperatures and at all voltages;
(2) In terms of mass and size, the new heater must be as small and light as possible;
(3) In terms of usability and cost, the use of rare earth materials and Pb must be avoided, while the cost of the new product must be competitive;
(4) In terms of safety, any risk of electric shock or scalding accidents must be prevented under all conditions.
Among the existing concepts of electric heaters for automobiles, the most popular are PTC heaters with resistors made of barium titanate (BaTiO3) with a positive temperature coefficient. For this reason, several details of its operating principle are explained and it is compared with a laminar heater developed according to the HVH for high voltage heaters.
Although the self-limiting characteristics of the PTC element can in some respects make the design of the system, particularly for failure modes, easier, it has certain inherent drawbacks, the main ones of which include:
(1) The need for Pb doping when the PTC temperature exceeds 120°C. In order to ensure rapid heat transfer in a small package size, PTC elements need to operate in the temperature range where Pb doping is necessary when applying automotive coolant heaters;
(2) The application of the rare earth metal La is very common for PTCs;
(3) The non-linear resistance/temperature profile that results in a high starting current when energised, combined with the high thermal resistance of the PTC element, makes the response time of the PTC heater relatively slow;
(4) The lower PTC temperature results in less heat being transferred to the coolant, thus reducing thermal performance as the coolant temperature increases;
(5) As the PTC temperature becomes lower, the thermal performance decreases as the voltage decreases, thus limiting heat transfer. (6) As the temperature of the PTC element is directly related to the applied voltage, it is difficult to control at part load.





